Vaccination Benefits and Safety
Introduction to Vaccination Benefits
- Vaccination programs have enabled the elimination or control of many serious infectious diseases worldwide over the past 200 years, according to the Autoimmunity Reviews 1
- The potential benefits of influenza vaccination alone in preventing serious illness, hospitalization, and death greatly outweigh the possible risks, as stated by the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 3, 4
Influenza Vaccination Benefits
- During different epidemics from 1972-1981, influenza-associated hospitalization rates ranged from 200-300 per million for healthy persons aged 5-44 years and 2,000-10,000 per million for persons aged >65 years, as reported by the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 3
Safety Profile of Vaccines
- For influenza vaccines, investigations indicate no substantial increase in Guillain-Barré Syndrome (GBS), with a risk of approximately one additional case per million persons vaccinated, according to the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 3, 5
- The risk of GBS from influenza vaccines is substantially less than the risk of severe influenza complications that vaccination prevents, as stated by the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 3, 5
- The average case-fatality ratio for GBS is 6% and increases with age, but there is no evidence that this ratio differs between vaccinated and unvaccinated persons, as reported by the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 4
- Thimerosal concerns have been addressed with increased availability of preservative-free vaccines, though evidence does not show harm from thimerosal-containing vaccines, according to the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 6
Addressing Vaccine Hesitancy
- Japan experienced recrudescence of pertussis and measles after decades of vaccine reluctance, as stated by the Autoimmunity Reviews 1
- Healthcare providers should strongly endorse all universally recommended vaccines as important for health rather than presenting them as optional, according to the Pediatrics journal 7
- Parents often express concerns about pain associated with multiple injections (44%), receiving too many vaccines at once (34%), development of autism or learning difficulties (26%), chronic illnesses (13.5%), and inadequate safety testing (13.2%), as reported by the Pediatrics journal 8, 9
Evidence-Based Communication Strategies
- Discussion of benefits and risks of vaccination is sound medical practice and required by law, as stated by the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 10
- Vaccine Information Statements must be provided by all public and private vaccination providers each time a vaccine is administered, according to the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 10
- A guiding style ("May I help you?") is more effective than a directing style ("This is what you should do"), as reported by the Pediatrics journal 7
Common Misconceptions and Scientific Facts
- The number of immunogenic proteins and polysaccharides in modern vaccines is actually smaller than in earlier vaccines, as stated by the Pediatrics journal 8
- Concerns about immune system overload are unfounded based on scientific evidence, according to the Pediatrics journal 8
- No scientifically conclusive evidence exists of harm from thimerosal preservative-containing vaccines, as reported by the MMWR Recommendations and Reports 6